Fidelity Brokerage Account Reviews

Summary of a Reddit comment

Nearly 20 years at Fidelity with most net worth there, but a routine transfer to the CMA was held 26 days without notice, leaving bills unpaid and meeting no empathy; moved everything to Schwab and is pleased with it.

Summary of a Reddit comment

They call Fidelity Baskets horrible because some of their positions are stuck in limbo. They were told the engineering team would take about a week to respond.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Long-time clients with a supposed advisor and team who never contacts them; zero contact is the worst experience in about 40 years with Fidelity.

Summary of a Reddit comment

A customer since the 1990s who noticed a terrible drop in service after being dropped from the Private Client Group, with questions unanswered and promised callbacks that never came.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Support and ops were great about researching an unexplained old transfer fee, but the advisor they were sent to belittled their Boglehead investing strategy.

Summary of a Reddit comment

After a parent's death it took over a month, two visits to different Fidelity offices and countless calls and emails to transfer an IRA to them, so they are moving it to another company.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Fidelity is their least favorite of three brokers; a fraudulent debit charge on the cash account took months to recover and support was rude and bad on other calls, until they wrote the executive office.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Deposit was held for a month after being told three days, with support unable to help and many others reporting similar holds, which pushed them to choose Vanguard.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Was locked out of Fidelity for six weeks, lost money as a result, and split investments across two brokerages afterwards.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Employer direct deposits were held two weeks in a row in the CMA, tying up thousands of dollars, so they returned to a real bank for spending.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Called after hours about a possible phishing message and Fidelity locked all accounts and cards, cancelled pending bill payments and gave different answers on every follow-up call.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Had Fidelity as a one-stop shop for years until it rolled out a 20-day hold with no prior notice, which showed it was no longer customer-service aligned.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Fees and a very hard time closing the account; the agent would not let them move their investment.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Has Fidelity accounts only because of an employer 401k and cannot wait to close them, finding the site difficult and not intuitive and customer service middling, with no bank behind it.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Two weeks of secure emails, four form submissions and phone calls have failed to get their retirement accounts unrestricted after a data-refresh letter in an obscure folder, with no email or text warning beforehand.

Summary of a Reddit comment

After transferring in $100k, had a terrible customer service experience over an old 401k that was never fully closed, with about 10 cents left, and was told closing it would cost a $75 fee they had already paid.

Summary of a Reddit comment

For several years has been unable to change the primary beneficiary online, getting an error each time, and also needs multiple tries to log in with the system reporting wrong credentials.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Has held FXAIX for ten years but is cutting ties with Fidelity, citing a clunky user interface, poor IT, incompetent assistance and childish responses when closing accounts.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Likes Fidelity's platform but is fighting after it inappropriately disbursed their entire 457(b) from a previous employer without the 60-day decision window, with hours on the phone and a big tax hit looming.

Summary of a Reddit comment

They opened a Fidelity account but, after changing phone numbers, could not log in or verify it. Two calls to customer service confirmed only an in-person visit could unlock it, so they went elsewhere.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Says deposits initiated from within Fidelity were put on hold last year for 10 days to a month due to security scams, while transfers started from the bank took at most three days.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Moving most money from Fidelity to Schwab after noticing customer service slip over the past year, with inaccurate information and no urgency to solve problems caused by Fidelity's system limits; leaving only a small amount behind.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Tried to set up an IRA with Fidelity and found customer service unhelpful, then got quick assistance at Schwab, where the IRA opened fast and the 401k rollover was easy.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Living overseas, tried three times to withdraw from Fidelity, which needed to phone to verify identity but apparently could not place an overseas call; moved everything to Schwab once back in the States.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Premier customer of 18 years who got a mailed notice that Fidelity was closing all accounts with no warning or explanation; can only sell or transfer out, and the Premier rep could not say what triggered it.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Tried for weeks to open an account at Fidelity, talking to multiple support reps who filed several tickets without getting it done, then opened a Schwab account instead and calls Fidelity's customer service incompetent.

Summary of a Reddit comment

After 40 years finds the new Trader Pro very user unfriendly, and says Fidelity told them they were out of luck on several complaints, so plans to close their accounts.

Summary of a Reddit comment

A payroll direct deposit was held two weeks for fraud protection with no recourse, so after release they closed all Fidelity accounts except a 401k they are stuck with.

Summary of a Reddit comment

A minor account name change took 15 minutes at Schwab, but Fidelity's branch forced a separate appointment a week later and the reps were rude and not punctual.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Held a Fidelity account for about 18 years, but moving a 401k to an IRA took five weeks the first time and three weeks the second, unlike Schwab where problems were resolved the same day.

Summary of a Reddit comment

A 401k to rollover IRA move within Fidelity became a runaround of repeated notarizations that were then left to expire, and only a transfer request from Schwab finally got the money out.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Started with Fidelity after Vanguard, then had accounts locked for fraud over a transfer from their own bank, waited an hour on hold, and got access back after about three weeks without explanation.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Fidelity held deposits for six weeks at a time and fractional shares vanished on transfer, so everything moved to Schwab with no regrets.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Warns that Fidelity cancels and freezes accounts without any notice and then tells customers they have 30 days to transfer out, with protests going nowhere.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Has both and finds Fidelity customer service far worse than Schwab's; after a nasty exchange with the active trading group, which would not match Schwab's per-contract fee, plans to close Fidelity and move to Robinhood.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Heavy rapid day trading in one stock led Fidelity to permanently shut down their account without warning, though they say Fidelity has excellent price improvement.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Liked getting ATM fees reimbursed overseas but dislikes the account overall; after reporting unauthorized card use and cancelling the card, got only one call and no follow-up on the dispute.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Used both for years and closed Fidelity because Schwab has hands-down better customer service, gradually migrating everything there.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Active Trader Pro does not save chart or configuration changes, and recently dividends were sent to cash instead of being reinvested; an issue reported over a year ago was never fixed.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Says Fidelity customer service ends when the CMA has a problem because the banking is outsourced; they were bounced back and forth for a long time and moved banking elsewhere about ten years ago.

Summary of a Reddit post

They paid extra for Fidelity Baskets after consolidating M1 accounts there, hit a failed rebalance with funds stuck pending, and got no callback for weeks, leaving them regretting the move.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Had many issues opening the account, cannot log in via Chrome, and transfers are slow: one took three weeks and a Roth transfer took two months, so most money went to Vanguard.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Moved a significant Fidelity account to Schwab because Fidelity seems to give bad customer service to anyone who is a DIY investor.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Long-term Fidelity customer who finds the extended holds ridiculous and says its customer service model seems to have changed for the worse, so is looking for a new home and moved many assets to IBKR.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Says the Fidelity advisor pushed hard to move their 401k into a managed account for a larger fee and kept calling afterwards, leaving a poor impression.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Almost 30 years as a customer, account locked for three months when trying to withdraw.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Plans to move all Fidelity assets to Schwab after finding administrative tasks a nightmare, with reps giving different answers each time, the back office dropping the ball, and archaic manual forms as power of attorney.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Was erroneously banned from Fidelity and still has not been reinstated, so would be reluctant to consolidate on its platform.

Summary of a Reddit comment

An experienced options trader says a market order on an illiquid option filled far below the bid shown in the Fidelity app, and Fidelity support would not reverse it, so they advise always using limit orders.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Locking an HSA with Fidelity's transfer lock earlier this year blocked reimbursing themself from the HSA with an unhelpful error.

Summary of a Reddit post

They hit a bug in Fidelity Baskets where one basket would not save ticker changes and recurring investments kept buying unwanted stocks. Support called baskets a niche product, and they are now looking at alternatives.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Based on their own experiences, finds Fidelity customer service horrible when dealing with complex issues.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Moved IRAs from Fidelity to Schwab because of the website and customer support, after their spouse also disliked the Fidelity site.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Years ago asked Fidelity for advice on a 403b and says they would not give any, only becoming helpful once they wanted the account, so is skeptical that any brokerage firm is really good.

Summary of a Reddit comment

After decades of stellar service, the latest advisor appointment turned into a hard annuity sales pitch that a financially trained customer found tacky and deceptive.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Complains that Fidelity keeps calling at odd hours even after being asked to stop, and the person calling was rude.

Summary of a Reddit post

They say Fidelity closed their long-held account after they withdrew funds to buy ETFs, gave no details when they called support, then asked for proof of their job while their money sat idle.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Fidelity locked their account once and since then they moved to Schwab, which they say is way better.

Summary of a Reddit comment

Stuck with Schwab for over a decade because Fidelity tends to hold deposits for weeks and its CMA is not a fully regulated bank, with horror stories when a problem lands with its partner banks.

Summary of a Reddit comment

A branch visit to learn how to transfer a pension to a Roth IRA meant a two-hour runaround in the lobby before the staff said they needed more research.